Could vs should in decision making

Researchers from Harvard Business School were curious about the dilemmas where two good values pull in opposite directions, and whether the question we ask ourselves changes the answer we find. In one study they gave 310 full-time employees a tough case to handle.

They were the president of a charity fighting child labour, and a company accused of using child labour had just offered them a $200,000 donation. Before writing a speech announcing their decision, half were primed to ask "What should I do?" and half to ask "What could I do?"

Spending time with could, could be a good move.

In the "could" group, 47% came up with a solution that honoured both sides of the dilemma rather than sacrificing one, compared with 29% of the "should" group, who were more likely to simply turn the money down. The "could" thinkers also considered more options, and judges rated their decisions as better quality and no less ethical. When the researchers ran a version with pairs talking it through, 53% of people in "What could we do?" pairs found that kind of solution, against 32% of people in "What should we do?" pairs.

Good judgment at work often means keeping the conversation open long enough to find a better option.

How to apply this approach:

  1. Change the first question: When someone brings you a tricky call involving a customer, a colleague or a policy, start with "What could we do here?" and save "What should we do?" for later.

  2. Ask for one more option: Before deciding, invite everyone to suggest at least one path that keeps both concerns in play, even if it feels like a stretch.

  3. Then bring "should" back in: Once you have a fuller list, use your values to weigh which option you can stand behind.

One small word changed how people thought, which makes it about the cheapest ethics training you'll ever find.

If you'd like help building better decision conversations in your organisation, grab a free 30 minute consultation with me.

Source

Zhang, T., Gino, F., & Margolis, J. D. (2018). Does "could" lead to good? On the road to moral insight. Academy of Management Journal, 61(3), 857-895.

Next
Next

Make your vision visible